Finance Research Letters · 2026
Diversified but Crowded: Evidence from 13F Holdings
Volume 113 (December 2026) · Article 110885 · First available online October 8, 2026
Abstract
Can an institution diversify internally while becoming more similar to its peers? Using filing-resolved SEC Form 13F holdings for the 500 largest reported portfolios each quarter from 2013Q2 through 2025Q4, we measure manager crowding as mean pairwise minimum-weight overlap. In regressions with quarter fixed effects, portfolio controls, and manager-clustered standard errors, entropy is positively associated with crowding (β = 0.067, SE = 0.003). A one-standard-deviation entropy difference in the estimation sample corresponds to 0.082 greater crowding, or 50.6% of the mean. Within the quarterly reselected top-500 sample, mean crowding rises from 0.129 to 0.230, while the random-breadth benchmark rises by 0.019; this aggregate trend combines portfolio changes with changes in sample composition. Security-popularity and same-quarter peer-consensus diagnostics sharply attenuate the association; exact large-manager exclusions leave it nearly unchanged. These descriptive results concern reported long positions, not complete portfolios or causal effects. They show that within-portfolio diversification and cross-institution distinctiveness are separate dimensions.
Free access to the published version
Read or download the Version of Record through Elsevier’s Share Link before December 2, 2026, with no registration or payment required. This is a limited free-access window; the DOI and publisher page remain the permanent publication links.
Published citation
Hu, L., & Shen, Y. (2026). Diversified but crowded: Evidence from 13F holdings. Finance Research Letters, 113, 110885. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2026.110885.
At a glance
The analysis distinguishes concentration within a portfolio from similarity across portfolios. The results are descriptive associations for reported long positions, rather than estimates of causal effects or institutions’ complete balance-sheet exposures.
Venue rankings & metrics
Finance Research Letters · Sources checked October 5, 2026
- SJRQ12025
SCImago Journal Rank quartile: Q1 in Finance, 2025.
SCImago · Finance Research Letters ↗- CiteScore10.1publisher display
CiteScore 10.1 in the current publisher listing, checked October 5, 2026. Metric year is not stated in the readable listing.
Elsevier · Finance Research Letters ↗- JIF7.1publisher display
Journal Impact Factor 7.1 in the current publisher listing, checked October 5, 2026. Metric year is not stated in the readable listing.
Elsevier · Finance Research Letters ↗- SJR1.6722025
SCImago Journal Rank indicator, 2025.
SCImago · Finance Research Letters ↗
SJR Q1 refers to SCImago's 2025 Finance category, not a JCR or CAS classification. CiteScore and JIF are the publisher's current displayed values; the readable publisher listing does not state their metric year.
Citation · BibTeX
@article{hu2026diversified,
title = {Diversified but crowded: Evidence from {13F} holdings},
author = {Hu, Liang and Shen, Yinru},
journal = {Finance Research Letters},
volume = {113},
year = {2026},
month = dec,
pages = {110885},
doi = {10.1016/j.frl.2026.110885},
url = {https://doi.org/10.1016/j.frl.2026.110885}
}